Don’t Fight the Fed

Investors concerned about the prospect of future interest rate hikes by the Federal Reserve may find it beneficial to review the historical performance of balanced portfolios during previous periods of rising interest rates.

The following tables consolidate the performance of two proxy portfolios (Total Bond Market, Balanced Portfolio) during historical periods of rising rates.

In each of the periods evaluated, balanced portfolios decisively outperformed a bond market portfolio as measured by total return (CAGR), risk-adjusted return (Sharpe Ratio) and downside protection (Sortino).

October 1986 to February 1989.

Over the 29-month period the effective Fed Funds rate increased 388 bps from 5.99% to 9.87%. A nearly 12% CAGR for equities meant balanced portfolio outperformed by 280 bps.

October 1986-February 1989

CAGR

Standard Deviation

Max. Drawdown

Sharpe Ratio

Sortino Ratio

Balanced Portfolio

7.02%

7.69%

-8.09%

0.09

0.14

Total Bond Market

4.18%

5.48%

-5.86%

-0.39

-0.52

December 1992 to April 1995.

Over the 29-month period the effective Fed Funds rate increased 289 bps from 3.17% to 6.06%.

December 1992 – April 1995

CAGR

Standard Deviation

Max. Drawdown

Sharpe Ratio

Sortino Ratio

Balanced Portfolio

7.34%

4.87%

-5.47%

0.70

1.02

Total Bond Market

5.97%

4.07%

-5.01%

0.51

0.75

January 1999 to September 2000.

A 21-month period that saw the effective Fed Funds rate increase 253 bps from 4.07% to 6.60%

January 1999 – September 2000

CAGR

Standard Deviation

Max. Drawdown

Sharpe Ratio

Sortino Ratio

Balanced Portfolio

5.87%

5.69%

-2.17%

0.13

0.20

Total Bond Market

3.56%

3.20%

-2.64%

-0.50

-0.64

June 2004 – August 2006.

A 27-month period when the effective Fed Funds rate increased 429 bps from 1.02% to 5.31%.

June 2004 – August 2006

CAGR

Standard Deviation

Max. Drawdown

Sharpe Ratio

Sortino Ratio

Balanced Portfolio

5.54%

2.82%

-1.60%

0.79

1.35

Total Bond Market

4.06%

3.05%

-1.90%

0.28

0.42

Investors are best served by remaining focused on the long-term and relying upon diversified portfolios to maximize risk-adjusted returns. Despite the periods of rising rates illustrated above, the 239-month period beginning in October 1986 and ending in August 2006 (nearly 20-years) saw a balanced portfolio produce superior risk-adjusted returns compared to either a 100% bond or 100% stock portfolio.

October 1986 – August 2006

CAGR

Standard Deviation

Max. Drawdown

Sharpe Ratio

Sortino Ratio

Large Cap US Equity

11.34%

15.0%

-44.82%

0.49

0.71

Balanced Portfolio

8.56%

5.6%

-8.09%

0.69

1.09

Total Bond Market

7.01%

4.1%

-5.86%

0.58

0.88

Latest

Navigating the Rate Cut: A Guide for Advisors

Introduction The ongoing Federal Reserve cycle has sparked intense debate...

My 50-Cents – Fed Analysis from Leland Abrams of Wynkoop, LLC

The Federal Reserve Board cut their benchmark rate this...

A Summer Surge: August 2024 HANDLS Monthly Report

After a challenging July that saw investors sell off high-flying technology stocks, buyers returned to the market in August, bidding up risk assets across the board.

Where are the Hidden Risks in Your Portfolio Currently? Plus, an idea.

Allocators add new exposures for a variety of reasons; diversification, returns, risk mitigation, etc. Understanding this, what is the most over-owned and expensive sector today?

Newsletter

Don't miss

Navigating the Rate Cut: A Guide for Advisors

Introduction The ongoing Federal Reserve cycle has sparked intense debate...

My 50-Cents – Fed Analysis from Leland Abrams of Wynkoop, LLC

The Federal Reserve Board cut their benchmark rate this...

A Summer Surge: August 2024 HANDLS Monthly Report

After a challenging July that saw investors sell off high-flying technology stocks, buyers returned to the market in August, bidding up risk assets across the board.

Where are the Hidden Risks in Your Portfolio Currently? Plus, an idea.

Allocators add new exposures for a variety of reasons; diversification, returns, risk mitigation, etc. Understanding this, what is the most over-owned and expensive sector today?

Consumer Spending: Are Consumers Tapped Out or Pushing Back?

Consumer Spending: Are Consumers Tapped Out or Pushing Back?  Key...
David Cohen
David Cohen
Dave Cohen is Cofounder of Bryant Avenue Ventures, an index provider which is implemented in a targeted distribution strategy at Strategy Shares. He previously served as Managing Director of Product Development at Guggenheim Investments. Dave is a product development executive with more than 20 years of experience creating successful financial products across a variety of asset classes and investment vehicles.

Navigating the Rate Cut: A Guide for Advisors

Introduction The ongoing Federal Reserve cycle has sparked intense debate regarding its resemblance to the 2007 and 1998 financial crises. While a definitive answer remains...

My 50-Cents – Fed Analysis from Leland Abrams of Wynkoop, LLC

The Federal Reserve Board cut their benchmark rate this week by 50 bps to a new range of 4.75% - 5.00%.  They indicated this...

A Summer Surge: August 2024 HANDLS Monthly Report

After a challenging July that saw investors sell off high-flying technology stocks, buyers returned to the market in August, bidding up risk assets across the board.